A Foodie's Guide to Manly and Freshwater Restaurants

Nestled along the picturesque Northern Beaches of Sydney, Manly and Freshwater offer a delightful fusion of natural beauty, coastal charm, and a vibrant food scene. From the sandy shores of Manly Beach to the tranquil waters of Freshwater, these seaside suburbs beckon both locals and visitors alike with their unique blend of relaxed beach vibes and exciting culinary adventures.

Both areas have a vibrant culinary scene, and we're here to help you find out just how good, with our foodie's guide to Manly and Freshwater restaurants on First Table. From long-standing favourites to hidden gems, these dining establishments offer a diverse range of flavours and experiences, catering to every food lover's palate.

Whether you're craving Italian classics, New York-inspired dishes, tapas-style delights, or an authentic Sardinian feast, these restaurants are sure to leave you with unforgettable dining memories.

Donny's

Legend has it that Donny worked both sides of the law, tipping off speakeasy establishments prior to raids, and planting false leads during the 1920s prohibition.  A sleuth of the Bureau of Prohibition, uncovering the depths of organised crime and mobster syndicates in New York City – or so they thought. Donny was registered as missing in 1928, his disappearance remains a mystery.

Also somewhat of a mystery is Donny's Bar, a hidden gem located on Market Lane, offering a unique blend of a New York-style loft bar and a fine dining experience. Specialising in New York strip steak, Charcuterie board and sharing platters, Donnys is a cosy fine-dining haven with urban cool decor.

To end the evening on a high note, Donny's offers an array of exquisite cocktails, including both classic and signature options, with standout choices like the sticky date espresso or hibiscus chilli margarita, expertly crafted by their talented bartenders

In Situ

In Situ Manly is a long-standing bar and restaurant located in Manly's iconic Northern Beaches. With a tried and true Italian menu, signature cocktails and live music in the evenings, it has become a favourite dining destination for over 20 years.

The menu is diverse, with something for everyone! Pizza, pasta, tapas, hearty mains, fresh seafood, salads and platters the list goes on, it's so hard to decide! In Situ is also home to the apple crumble martini and their signature hazelnut espresso martini plus a host of other classic cocktails, you're sure to find something to whet your liquid appetite.

The Cumberland

Embark on a mysterious journey as you step through a hidden door cleverly disguised behind a fridge in a bodega-style deli. Descending the stairs, you'll be transported to a stylish basement bar that evokes a bygone era, where classic cocktails reign supreme and impeccable service is paramount.

Their menu is a selection of tapas-style dishes, ideal for sharing and pairing. From their meticulously crafted terrine to artisanal cheeses and flavorful meatballs, each dish is thoughtfully prepared to ensure a memorable culinary experience.

And with 50 whiskies on offer, as well as natural wine and craft beer, The Cumberland is your go-to for an intimate date night or a gathering with friends.

Pilu at Freshwater

Drawing inspiration from his Sardinian roots, Giovanni Pilu's beachfront restaurant Pilu at Freshwater exudes a luxurious beach house vibe, surrounded by lush trees and breathtaking ocean views. The restaurant flawlessly combines the beauty of Sydney's coastal setting with the essence of Sardinia.

Pilu presents a thoughtfully crafted "The Sardinian Experience" 5-course menu that showcases authentic flavours. The menu highlights dishes like succulent roasted suckling pig complemented by tangy pickled walnut pesto. Other delights include chargrilled octopus with garlic and potato cream, as well as Sardinian pasta stuffed with potato and pecorino, served with burnt butter.

The gastronomy at Pilu remains true to its Sardinian heritage, offering uncomplicated yet delightful culinary creations.

Acqua Fresca by Pilu

Acqua Fresca's warm hospitality and stylish ambience make it the perfect destination for those seeking an unforgettable Italian dining experience in a relaxed setting.

Indulge in their four-course sharing menu, featuring mouthwatering antipasto options like house-made focaccia and crispy arancini balls, followed by a selection of classic pizzas including Capricciosa, Piccante, and 4 Formaggi.

For the pasta course, savour the delectable squidgy gnocchi, pappardelle with venison ragu, or orecchiette pasta with prawns, zucchini, and fresh pesto. To conclude this remarkable culinary journey, delight in the signature tiramisu by the renowned Giovanni Pilu. 

With a wide array of dining options to choose from, ranging from cozy cafes to fine-dining establishments, Manly and Freshwater have something for everyone. Whether you're a seafood aficionado or a lover of international cuisine, you're sure to find a dining experience that satisfies your cravings. Explore the bustling streets, savour the flavours, and immerse yourself in the coastal charm of Manly and Freshwater, a foodie's paradise with endless delights to discover.